Valero Trades at 60.91x Trailing Earnings, 14.85x Forward Amid Energy Growth
Valero's trailing P/E of 60.91 looks overvalued on history, but forward P/E of 14.85 prices in expected energy sector growth.
TL;DR:Valero's trailing P/E of 60.91 looks overvalued on history, but forward P/E of 14.85 prices in expected energy sector growth.
Key Takeaways
Valero's trailing P/E of 60.91 looks overvalued on history, but forward P/E of 14.85 prices in expected energy sector growth.
P/B ratio at 1.87-2.12 trades below sector average of 1.95, offering modest discount to book value for value hunters.
ROE of 2.76-5.24% lags sector's 12%, highlighting weak profitability amid refining margin squeezes.
PEG ratio of 1.36 signals growth potential despite premium P/E of 35.36x versus sector 22x.
Watch Q4 earnings and commodity margins to gauge if multiples compress on low 0.65% profit margins.
The Big Picture
Valero trades at a high trailing P/E of 60.91 versus forward P/E of 14.85, suggesting cyclical overvaluation on historical earnings but potential value on expected growth in the energy sector.
Why It Matters
VLO's elevated P/E of 35.36 signals a premium valuation, suggesting market expectations for robust future growth in the energy sector.
However, the modest ROE of 5.24% and P/B of 2.12 indicate limited profitability efficiency relative to book value, raising concerns about sustainability. Investors should assess if growth prospects justify these multiples against sector risks and execution challenges.
By The Numbers
-
P/E Ratio: 35.36x vs sector 22x
-
P/B Ratio: 2.12x vs sector 1.5x
-
ROE: 5.24% vs sector 12%
-
Market Cap: $53.6B vs peers $40B
-
PEG Ratio: Not reported
-
D/E Ratio: Not reported
-
Valuation Score: 68/100
The Details
Relative Valuation
Valero's trailing P/E ratio of 60.91 appears elevated, signaling potential overvaluation relative to current earnings, while the forward P/E of 14.85 suggests cheaper pricing on expected growth. P/B stands at 1.90, below the industry average of 1.95. This indicates the stock trades at a modest discount to book value peers, appealing for value investors.
Historical Context
Over the past year, VLO's P/B ranged from 1.25 to 1.89 (median 1.55), with the current 1.87 near the high end, and PEG from 1.36 to 3.45 (median 2.52). Trailing P/E has spiked to 60.91 amid Q3 2025 impairments, contrasting lower historical norms. ROE of 2.76% reflects recent pressures like refinery write-downs, down from prior strength.
Peer Comparison
VLO's PEG of 2.50 exceeds its recent low of 1.36 but trails the industry average of 1.55, implying less attractive growth pricing versus rivals. P/B of 1.87-1.90 is competitive against the sector's 1.95, with EV/EBITDA at 10.25 showing solid enterprise efficiency. Low margins (profit 0.65%) highlight cyclical peer
challenges
in refining.
Growth-Adjusted Metrics
Forward P/E of 14.85 and PEG of 2.50 incorporate 14.79% 5Y EPS growth forecasts, despite -2.44% revenue outlook, balancing optimism with
sector headwinds. EV/FCF of 15.49 remains reasonable post-Q3 $1.1B net income. Analysts' $154 target (4.85% upside) supports moderate growth appeal.
The Bottom Line
VLO trades at an elevated trailing P/E of 60.91 but a more reasonable forward P/E of 14.85, with P/B of ~1.9 below industry average and sources indicating undervaluation relative to fair value. Low margins (0.65% profit) and ROE (2.76%) reflect refining pressures, yet PEG of 1.36-2.50 suggests growth potential. Monitor Q4 earnings and commodity margins for multiple compression or expansion.
Stocks Covered
Related Resources
Written by ShareValue.ai Editorial Team — more on Value Investing from our editorial team.
11 expertise areas covered, including value, growth, dividend, quality, and macro analysis.
How ShareValue Scores Stocks
ShareValue's proprietary 4-Pillar Scoring Framework covers stocks, ETFs and funds worldwide and scores the qualified universe on four critical dimensions: Valuation, Quality, Growth, and Financial Health. Unlike traditional screeners that rely on single metrics, our scoring combines several fundamental measures to surface candidates for further research.
- •Deep Value Metrics: P/E, P/B, and P/S ratios to compare pricing against peers
- •Quality Indicators: ROE, profit margins, and operational efficiency to help flag value traps
- •Growth Trends: Revenue and earnings trends over time
- •Financial Stability: Debt levels, cash flow, and balance sheet strength
Our AI-powered analysis continuously monitors market data, identifying stocks that combine attractive valuations with solid fundamentals. This multi-dimensional view is a starting point for your own research, not a recommendation or a forecast.