Best Insurance - Property & Casualty Stocks in the United States for 2026

Top-ranked Insurance - Property & Casualty stocks in United States. P&C insurers earn combined-ratio income on short-tail underwriting plus invested float; a sub-95 ratio anchors Quality, reinsurance coverage sets the Health floor.

Property and Casualty Insurance earns combined-ratio income on short-tail underwriting plus float invested through the cycle. The Quality pillar (combined ratio under 95) and the Valuation pillar (price-to-book versus ROE) are the primary signals; Health pillar (reinsurance coverage, reserve adequacy) is the safety floor.

Data as of (updated daily)

Top 20 Insurance - Property & Casualty stocks in United States by composite score

#TickerNameComposite
1SLDE.USSlide Insurance Holdings, Inc. Common Stock71.4
2HCI.USHCI Group Inc67.4
3AII.USAmerican Integrity Insurance Group, Inc.64.7
4CINF.USCincinnati Financial Corporation64.0
5HRTG.USHeritage Insurance Hldgs Inc63.8
6ALL.USThe Allstate Corporation62.0
7KINS.USKingstone Companies Inc60.3
8WTM.USWhite Mountains Insurance Group Ltd59.0
9UVE.USUniversal Insurance Holdings Inc58.8
10ACIC.USAmerican Coastal Insurance Corp55.9
11TRV.USThe Travelers Companies Inc54.3
12SKWD.USSkyward Specialty Insurance Group, Inc. Common Stock54.0
13UFCS.USUnited Fire Group Inc53.6
14MCY.USMercury General Corporation53.5
15ORI.USOld Republic International Corp52.9
16AFG.USAmerican Financial Group, Inc.52.0
17THG.USThe Hanover Insurance Group Inc51.7
18PLMR.USPalomar Holdings Inc51.4
19ASIC.USAtegrity Specialty Insurance Company Holdings50.1
20BOW.USBowhead Specialty Holdings Inc.49.3

Customise the Insurance - Property & Casualty + United States screen

The full screener applies both filters and lets you stack 30+ more on top: market cap, dividend yield, and the four pillar scores.

Open in screener →

Methodology: How we score stocks. Data refreshed nightly around 03:30 ET. This page lists the top 20 by composite score within the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry, the United States. Use the screener for the full ranked list.

By using ShareValue.ai you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy. Educational platform, not investment advice.